Natural vs Unnatural acting

So I had a conversation with one of my Directors last night about my acting and how it was a little more difficult to edit bc every not every take of mine was the same and that, say with Michael, my co-star, his takes we're precisely choreographed and it was easier to edit. I told him every actor has his different method and I'm more of a natural actor. It's one thing if I'm given choreography for a scene (this entire scene was sitting at the dinner table) but if one take I'm caught up emotionally and I don't pick up the martini glass, I'm not going to stop the take bc of it. Maybe consistency within a take is something I need to work on but then why have the same take over and over? It doesn't allow options for edits right?